Advertisement

What if a Canadian pilot is shot down in ISIS territory?

WATCH ABOVE: King Abdullah II of Jordan vowed to wage a “harsh” war against the Islamic State in Syria. And now the Pentagon says the U.S. military will do more to help Jordan in that fight. Susan McGinnis reports from Washington, D.C.

The capture and barbaric murder of Jordanian fighter pilot Muath al-Kaseasbeh raises concerns about the dangers faced by pilots taking part in the airstrikes against ISIS and the plans in place to rescue a downed pilot.

If the execution was meant to frighten Jordan — or coalition members, including Canada – into withdrawing its support for and involvement in the U.S.-led bombing campaign against ISIS targets, it seems to have failed.  Jordan has vowed an “earth-shaking” response to avenge the murder of the 26-year-old pilot.

Jordan “temporarily” halted its sorties after the al-Kaseasbeh’s capture, but the pilot’s execution has prompted the government to ramp up its involvement in the anti-ISIS campaign.

Story continues below advertisement

READ MORE: Jordan launches new airstrikes after vowing harsh war on ISIS

And, Defence Minister Rob Nicholson showed no signs of Canada backing down either.

“Canada stands shoulder to shoulder with our allies against these acts of terror,” Nicholson affirmed on Wednesday, the same day Canadian fighter jets  launched airstrikes in Iraq, hitting a compound that was used as a staging area for extremists who’ve been launching guerilla-style raids into Baghdad.

Canadian aircraft are not known to have come under fire while carrying out or assisting with airstrikes in Iraq. But Canadian troops, who were sent to Iraq to support Kurdish Peshmerga fighters, have been fired at on at least three occasions.

READ MORE: Could feds’ anti-terror rhetoric hurt counter-terror strategies?

Rescuing a downed pilot is difficult enough when it happens on home soil, such as during a training operation, where resources are more readily accessible, said Dr. Eric Ouellet, a defence studies professor at the Royal Military College of Canada.

“We have the National Search and Rescue Secretariat here in Canada and then whoever is closest will be contacted for help, whether it’s the RCMP, the Coast Guard, the provincial police, etc.

“[But] when we talk about a downed pilot, over non-friendly territory… in that kind of situation the search and rescuers have to be protected themselves, for not being harmed or even becoming prisoners themselves,” he said.
Story continues below advertisement

The U.S. is the only country that really has the “capacity” to do such an operation, Ouellet said.

Breaking news from Canada and around the world sent to your email, as it happens.

READ MORE: Calls for #ISISMediaBlackout to stop spread of horrific ISIS images

Furthermore, there are different protocols for when an enemy captures a downed pilot.

“If a pilot is taken and it’s too dangerous to launch a combat search and rescue… then each nation would try to organize [a rescue mission] itself, with the help of allies.

“It depends where it is, but would usually involve special forces,” said Ouellet, who has an expertise in irregular warfare, counterinsurgency and strategic military command and decision-making.

There is normally a “memorandum of understanding” when militaries are involved in an international coalition such as this one.

Dept. of National Defence spokesperson Isabelle Bresse told Global News, in an e-mail, the Canadian Forces are “operating with military partners who are contributing combat search and rescue (CSAR) capabilities to this coalition.” She said those resources could be called on if needed.

Story continues below advertisement

“In order to protect the safety of our deployed aircrew and in the interests of operational security, we will not discuss the details regarding combat search and rescue procedures,” she said.

But for the United Arab Emirates (U.A.E.), another member of the coalition involved in anti-ISIS airstrikes, the concern for pilot safety was serious enough for the government to suspend its participation in the campaign shortly after ISIS took al-Kaseasbeh hostage.

The Guardian reported Wednesday “a lack of contingency plans to rescued downed aircrew” led to the U.A.E. decision.

“The United Arab Emirates are demanding that the Pentagon improve its search-and-rescue efforts, including the use of V-22 Osprey tilt-rotor aircraft, in northern Iraq, closer to the battleground, instead of basing the missions in Kuwait,” The New York Times reported, citing a U.S. official source.

READ MORE: Canadian warplanes destroy ISIS bomb factory, staging area

Like the U.S., Canada’s six CF-18 fighter jets, two Aurora CP-140 surveillance planes, a Polaris C-150 refueling jet, and some 600 Canadian Forces personnel, are stationed in Kuwait.

CNN reported late Wednesday the U.S. had begun moving search and rescue “assets” into northern Iraq, but that it was not because of the U.A.E. revelations.

ISIS claimed it shot down al-Kaseasbeh’s jet, but reports suggested it crashed due to mechanical failure.

Story continues below advertisement

The mechanical state of his jet may have led al-Kaseasbeh to his horrific fate, but Ouellet said “no plane is invincible.

“Even the most advanced plane will have eventually [have] some defect. It’s impossible to avoid completely.”

But as Ouellet explained, the logistics of a rescue operation depend on how dangerous an area they may need to go into.

READ MORE: ISIS demanded Sajida al-Rishawi’s release, now Jordan has executed her

Al-Kaseasbeh ejected from his F-16 fighter jet on Dec. 24,  after his aircraft went down while taking part in a bombing mission near Raqqa, Syria — an ISIS stronghold and the de-facto capital of its self-declared caliphate, the Islamic State.

The added concern with ISIS taking a foreign pilot hostage is that the Sunni militant group isn’t likely to respect the Geneva Convention relative to the treatment of prisoners of war.

“Prisoners of war must at all time be humanely treated,” the Convention states. “[P]risoners of war must at all time be protected, particularly against acts of violence or intimidation and against insults and public curiosity.”

Al-Kaeasbeh was paraded to his death, doused in fuel, locked in a cage and set ablaze. The video, posted to various websites on Tuesday, was reportedly screened on a large, outdoor screen in Raqqa for all to see.

Story continues below advertisement

Ouellet noted there have been debates over training pilots and other military personnel for the chance they could be captured.

“We’re not so sure, actually, of the value of that kind of training because it’s very hard on the people, but does it leave you with more capacity to escape if you ever face [that] situation.”

He said the first goal is to obviously to avoid being captured, but if a pilot or soldier is taken prisoner, they are only bound by their requirements under the Geneva Convention, which means providing only his or her “surname, first names and rank, date of birth, and army, regimental, personal or serial number, or failing this, equivalent information.”

Bresse would not confirm what training Canadian Air Forces members may or may not have for such situation, saying only CAF members “are well trained and we contribute in a significant manner to the coalition’s success in stopping the advance of [ISIS].”

With files from The Canadian Press

Sponsored content

AdChoices